House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Resolution Killed on a voice vote
The House took up 198 bills, listed below by bill.
Granite Record indexes the General Court’s record; it is not that record. Where a citation allows only one source, cite the General Court — every page here links to what it is drawn from. The date below is the day the page was read.
@misc{session-H-2009-03-24,
title = {The House, Tuesday, March 24, 2009},
howpublished = {Granite Record},
url = {https://graniterecord.org/session/H/2009-03-24},
note = {Accessed 19 Oct. 2026}
}The House assembled at 10:00 AM, a prayer was offered and Rep. Richard Drisko (R - Hills 5) led the Pledge of Allegiance.
Presiding over the House during the day: Rep. Terie Norelli (D - Rock 26), Speaker of the House, and Rep. Linda Foster (D - Hills 4).
The journal records 12 members as having leave of the House for the day, that is, permission to be away. A member on leave may still have voted on part of the day, and the roll call record does not always agree with the journal about who was excused.
Rep. Ronald Belanger (R - Rock 8) Rep. Paul Hackel (D - Hills 29) Rep. Alfred Lerandeau (D - Ches 12) Rep. Marcia Moody (D - Rock 17) Rep. Elisabeth Sanders (R - Rock 12) Rep. Michael Farley (D - Hills 15) Rep. Doreen Howard (D - Rock 12) Rep. Sarah Hutz (D - Straf 5) Rep. Susan Price (D - Straf 3) Rep. Joseph Russell (D - Rock 13) Rep. Don Van Patten (R - Rock 8) Rep. Burton Williams (R - Graf 8)
The record does not say what order these came in: the journal page is cited on only a few of them, so they are listed by bill.
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Resolution Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 17–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 10–8; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 203–138 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Susi Nord (D - Rock 1)
Spoke against the motionRep. John Hunt (R - Ches 7)
House Finance recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 20–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0103h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0103h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Education recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Children and Family Law recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0804h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0804h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0804h (New Title)
House Education recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Education recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0555h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0555h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Executive Departments and Administration recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 15–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Education recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0213h, 18–1.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0213h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Municipal and County Government recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0778h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0778h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Commerce recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 18–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 18–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–5; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
Spoke for the motionRep. Philip Preston (D - Graf 8)
Spoke against the motionRep. Lawrence Perkins (R - Rock 20) Rep. David Nixon (D - Hills 17)
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–9.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 314–35 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Susan Almy (D - Graf 11) Rep. David Bettencourt (R - Rock 4)
Spoke against the motionRep. Charles Weed (D - Ches 16)
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0041h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0041h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0041h (New Title)
House Ways and Means recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 20–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 11–6; a minority, Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL).
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Failed 163–209 on a division
Spoke for the motionRep. David Nixon (D - Hills 17)
Spoke against the motionRep. William Smith (R - Rock 18) Rep. William O'Brien (R - Hills 5)
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
In the record: Inexpedient to Legislate (Rep Kurk)
House Public Works and Highways recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 12–2.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0385h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0385h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0385h (New Title)
House Ways and Means recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0823h, 12–8.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0823h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes 191–155 on a division
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Children and Family Law recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0708h, 12–8; a minority, Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL).
Lay on the Table (Set the bill aside)
Motion Passed: Bill Tabled 330–44 on a division
In the record: Lay on the Table (Rep W.O'Brien)
Also spoke during this billRep. Cynthia Dokmo (R - Hills 6) Rep. Gary Richardson (D - Merr 10)the record does not say which of the day's motions
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0648h, 15–3.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0648h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0648h (New Title)
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0299h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0299h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0299h (New Title)
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Labor, Industrial and Rehabilitative Services recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–7; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 209–159 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Mary Gorman (D - Hills 31) Rep. John Knowles (D - Hills 27) Rep. Jeffrey Goley (D - Hills 21)
Spoke against the motionRep. Karen Umberger (R - Carr 1) Rep. W. Douglas Scamman (R - Rock 13)
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0721h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0721h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0653h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0653h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 12–5; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 196–154 on a division
Spoke for the motionRep. Eric Stohl (R - Coos 1)
Spoke against the motionRep. Carol Friedrich (D - Graf 16)
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0258h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0258h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0799h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0799h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Executive Departments and Administration recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 14–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0765h, 12–8; a minority, Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL).
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0765h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes 221–143 on a division
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 16–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–9; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 228–148 on a roll call
Spoke against the motionRep. David Hess (R - Merr 24) Rep. Peter Silva
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0255h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0255h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Legislative Administration recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 12–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Finance recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0726h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0726h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0726h (New Title)
House Municipal and County Government recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0850h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0850h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0850h (New Title)
House Judiciary recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0553h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0553h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0772h, 15–2.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0772h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0901h, 18–1.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0901h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0901h (New Title)
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0848h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0848h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Executive Departments and Administration recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0805h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0805h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0805h (New Title)
House Science, Technology and Energy recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL); a minority, Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 224–131 on a division
Spoke for the motionRep. Robert Matheson (D - Graf 4)
Spoke against the motionRep. Carol Friedrich (D - Graf 16) Rep. Gene Andersen (D - Graf 11)
House Labor, Industrial and Rehabilitative Services recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 20–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0750h, 16–1.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0750h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0750h (New Title)
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 12–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Education recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 18–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Municipal and County Government recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0824h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0824h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0824h (New Title)
House Municipal and County Government recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0856h, 13–1.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0856h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0574h, 18–2.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0574h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0574h (New Title)
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Municipal and County Government recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 16–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0404h, 12–4; a minority, Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL).
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0404h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes 222–137 on a roll call
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0404h (New Title)
Spoke for the motionRep. David Campbell (D - Hills 33)
Spoke against the motionRep. John Hikel (R - Hills 6)
House Children and Family Law recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 16–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Legislative Administration recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0549h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0549h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 15–5; a minority, Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Failed 169–203 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Eric Stohl (R - Coos 1) Rep. Mary Beth Walz (D - Merr 23)
Spoke against the motionRep. Susan Kepner (D - Rock 15) Rep. Steve Vaillancourt (R - Hills 15)
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0795h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
Reconsider (Vote again on a decision)
Motion Failed: Earlier Vote Stands on a voice vote
In the record: Reconsideration (Rep Vaillancourt)
Also spoke during this billRep. Steve Vaillancourt (R - Hills 15)the record does not say which of the day's motions
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–3.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0647h, 11–5; a minority, Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL).
Lay on the Table (Set the bill aside)
Motion Passed: Bill Tabled on a voice vote
In the record: Lay on the Table (Rep Hinch)
Also spoke during this billRep. Karen Umberger (R - Carr 1)the record does not say which of the day's motions
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Legislative Administration recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 12–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Education recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 12–6.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0803h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0803h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0803h (New Title)
House Municipal and County Government recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0900h, 18–2.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0900h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0900h (New Title)
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0840h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0840h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0840h (New Title)
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
The committee recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Science, Technology and Energy recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0873h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0873h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0873h (New Title)
House Finance recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0663h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0663h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Executive Departments and Administration recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Science, Technology and Energy recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0855h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0855h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0794h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0794h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0883h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0883h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–6.
Lay on the Table (Set the bill aside)
Motion Passed: Bill Tabled on a voice vote
In the record: Lay on the Table (Rep Walz)
House Municipal and County Government recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0612h, 15–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0612h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 17–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Public Works and Highways recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0435h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0435h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0782h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0782h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 12–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0635h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0635h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Labor, Industrial and Rehabilitative Services recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Executive Departments and Administration recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0516h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0516h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Children and Family Law recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 16–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0800h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0800h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0800h (New Title)
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0886h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0886h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 17–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 17–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Science, Technology and Energy recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 15–4; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Labor, Industrial and Rehabilitative Services recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–7; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 212–160 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Sally Kelly (D - Merr 20)
Spoke against the motionRep. William Smith (R - Rock 18) Rep. William Infantine (R - Hills 16)
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 19–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Resources, Recreation and Development recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 17–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Children and Family Law recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0920h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0920h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Education recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0632h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0632h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0569h, 13–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0569h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0569h (New Title)
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 15–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 8–4; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 10–8; a minority, Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 184–167 on a division
Spoke for the motionRep. Jennifer Coffey (R - Merr 6) Rep. Michael O'Brien (D - Hills 10)
Spoke against the motionRep. Mary Griffin (R - Rock 7) Rep. James Pilliod (R - Belk 5) Rep. Peter Schmidt (D - Straf 4)
House Education recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 18–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 17–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0405h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0405h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–9; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 216–160 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Philip Preston (D - Graf 8) Rep. Rick Ladd (R - Graf 5) Rep. Lucy Weber (D - Ches 2)
Spoke against the motionRep. William Smith (R - Rock 18) Rep. Leo Pepino (R - Hills 11) Rep. Pamela Tucker (R - Rock 23) Rep. Nancy Elliott (R - Hills 19)
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0697h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0697h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Public Works and Highways recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 14–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Public Works and Highways recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–2.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 20–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Public Works and Highways recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0281h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0281h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0746h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0746h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Science, Technology and Energy recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0895h, 19–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0895h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0773h, 18–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0773h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0687h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0687h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0687h (New Title)
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 15–4.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Finance recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 20–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Public Works and Highways recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 12–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 15–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Health, Human Services and Elderly Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0683h, 20–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0683h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 11–9; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 222–146 on a roll call
Spoke for the motionRep. Frances Potter (D - Merr 10) Rep. Lucy Weber (D - Ches 2)
Spoke against the motionRep. Anthony DiFruscia (R - Rock 4)
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0846h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0846h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0846h (New Title)
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 16–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 20–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Environment and Agriculture recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0123h, 16–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0123h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Transportation recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 12–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Finance recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 21–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Public Works and Highways recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 13–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 20–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0845h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0845h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Judiciary recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 18–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Finance recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 20–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Criminal Justice and Public Safety recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0709h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0709h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–1.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Children and Family Law recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0690h, 15–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0690h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Children and Family Law recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0689h, 17–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0689h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Ways and Means recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 11–8.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House Science, Technology and Energy recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 19–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
Spoke for the motionRep. Frank Holden (R - Hills 4)
Spoke against the motionRep. John Reagan (R - Rock 1)
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–3; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed 220–117 on a division
House Local and Regulated Revenues recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 16–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Killed on a voice vote
House Executive Departments and Administration recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 16–1.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 13–1.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Bill Passed on a voice vote
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0864h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0864h
Motion Passed: Resolution Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0864h (New Title)
House Commerce and Consumer Affairs recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0667h, 11–6.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0667h
Motion Passed: Resolution Passed with Changes 192–150 on a roll call
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0667h (New Title)
Spoke for the motionRep. Jill Hammond (D - Hills 24)
Spoke against the motionRep. John Hunt (R - Ches 7)
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 8–7; a minority, Ought to Pass (OTP).
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Resolution Killed 232–114 on a division
Spoke for the motionRep. Al Baldasaro (R - Rock 5)
Spoke against the motionRep. Charles Weed (D - Ches 16) Rep. Kris Roberts (D - Ches 16)
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL), 14–0.
Inexpedient to Legislate (ITL, Kill the bill)
Motion Passed: Resolution Killed on a voice vote
House State-Federal Relations and Veterans Affairs recommended Ought to Pass (OTP), 14–0.
Ought to Pass (OTP, Pass the bill)
Motion Passed: Resolution Passed on a voice vote
House Legislative Administration recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0654h, 12–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0654h
Motion Passed: Resolution Passed with Changes on a voice vote
House Municipal and County Government recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0793h, 14–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0793h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote
In the record: Ought to Pass with Amendment #0793h (New Title)
House Public Works and Highways recommended Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA) with amendment 0783h, 12–0.
Ought to Pass with Amendment (OTPA, Pass the bill with changes) 0783h
Motion Passed: Bill Passed with Changes on a voice vote